Skip to content
Bits&Chips
×

Your cart is currently empty!

×
Memberships
Advertising
Magazines
Videos
Contact

Log in

Martijn Heck is professor in photonic integration at Eindhoven University of Technology.

Opinion

Universities: cut the bullshit, not the budget

27 November 2024
Reading time: 3 minutes

Rather than just protesting budget cuts, universities need to take a good look in the mirror: if European economies aren’t innovative enough, academia shares in the blame, argues Martijn Heck.

Massive protests against budget cuts for Dutch universities are currently being prepared, and the Netherlands isn’t alone in this. In the UK, university bankruptcies are feared, while in the US, president-elect Trump is threatening to close the Department of Education. Science and education are under fire of shrinking government budgets and, in some cases, anti-establishment sentiments.

In a way, I understand this. What goes up, must come down: there’s no infinite growth model, and after years of investments, sometimes cuts need to follow.

Universities argue that education is a prerequisite for innovation and that every euro spent on research pays for itself many times over. They also argue that science underpins a free and developed society and that freedom in research in humanities, arts and natural sciences is essential for that. (On a side note: the engineering sciences are typically not included in that reasoning, but let’s not get distracted.) In general, I agree with all of that. These are all valid arguments for why budget cuts are bad for society and the economy.

However, the European economy is already stagnating without these cuts. It hardly shows any productivity growth, as emphasized by the Draghi report. While we sell handbags, champagne and make-up and count L’Oréal, Hermes and LVMH among our largest EU companies, the US dominates in AI and data, with the so-called FAANG companies, and Asia dominates in semiconductors, with Samsung and TSMC.

Cash-cow studies lead to bullshit jobs

Still, unemployment isn’t low: most people have jobs and there are many vacancies. The only conclusion can be that we’re massively not doing the right things. We’re active in markets that neither have the growth nor the strategic value. That’s worrying. And the worst part is that we know this: many people realize they don’t really contribute and have so-called “bullshit jobs,” by their own account.

Since universities are self-proclaimed pillars of the economy, they share part of the blame for this. If science and education are so important, then we need some self-reflection. What are we doing wrong? Are we educating the right people? At the right level? In the right fields? Education is a means to a goal and therefore budget for universities is too. Rather than only worrying about budget cuts, I worry about whether we have the right strategy too.

There are obvious problems in academia. A major issue is the quantity-over-quality discussion. Students are a business model for universities, as tuition fees are a main source of income. The economic laws then tell us that universities will lower standards and will set up new, easy and popular studies. Are these so-called cash-cow studies contributing significantly to innovation and productivity? I doubt it. Moreover, all those cash-cow students aren’t choosing much-needed professional and vocational studies.

Another problem is that universities don’t seem to align their portfolio of education. Most policymakers will agree that engineering studies are key to innovation. Then why are there more programs for gender studies, archaeology, astronomy and theology than, for example, electrical engineering? Labor markets matter.

Of course, we’ll always need such explorative and free-thinking educational programs and research fields, as they contribute to our society in many other ways than purely economic. The strategic question is: how many of them do we need and for how many students?

Untargeted budget cuts for universities are bad for an innovative economy. However, the current debate lacks substance and we’re not capitalizing on opportunities. Universities seem to look backward, afraid to lose, rather than forward, aiming for growth. Panta rhei, things change: we might need to cut to invest. I would urge governments to formulate a vision and a strategy for universities, rather than just cutting budgets. The Dutch Beethoven plan to support semicon is a start, but too ad-hoc and only focused on one field.

We need to manage the talent pipeline better with a long-term strategy, to prepare the population for the future economy. We owe it to the taxpayers and the young people, the prospective students. Cash-cow studies lead to bullshit jobs. It’s all in the name.

Related content

Drilling for boring

TUE puts semiconductor and systems innovation research under one roof

Top jobs
Your vacancy here?
View the possibilities
in the media kit
wurth
Events
Courses
Headlines
  • Semi: advanced nodes take the lead in global fab expansion

    3 July 2025
  • Salland Electronics shuts down

    2 July 2025
  • Tomtom navigates 300 job cuts in AI-driven restructuring

    1 July 2025
  • SRON’s Ilse Aben awarded Stevin Prize

    30 June 2025
  • TU Delft demonstrates spin transport in graphene without magnets

    30 June 2025
  • Eugène Reuvekamp to lead Chiptech Twente

    24 June 2025
  • Intel publishes 18A PPA improvements

    24 June 2025
  • Superlight launches compact wideband laser for industrial spectroscopy

    23 June 2025
  • TUE puts semiconductor and systems innovation research under one roof

    20 June 2025
  • OrangeQS secures €12M to scale quantum chip testing

    19 June 2025
  • NLR and Photonfirst to deploy fiber‑optic sensing in helicopter fleet

    18 June 2025
  • Quantware raises $27M to fast-track million-qubit quantum computers

    18 June 2025
  • New Origin foundry seeks additional €40M investment

    17 June 2025
  • US pushes Netherlands, others to tighten export curbs

    17 June 2025
  • Wil van de Wiel relieves John van Soerland at the Xiver wheel

    17 June 2025
  • World’s first 2D-material CMOS computer makes debut

    12 June 2025
  • Besi lifts sales forecast

    12 June 2025
  • Marcelo Ackermann to head ARCNL

    12 June 2025
  • European InP pilot line lands on High Tech Campus

    11 June 2025
  • Imec reworks forksheet to ease GAA manufacturability

    11 June 2025
Bits&Chips logo

Bits&Chips strengthens the high tech ecosystem in the Netherlands and Belgium and makes it healthier by supplying independent knowledge and information.

Bits&Chips focuses on news and trends in embedded systems, electronics, mechatronics and semiconductors. Our coverage revolves around the influence of technology.

Advertising
Subscribe
Events
Contact
High-Tech Systems Magazine (Dutch)
(c) Techwatch bv. All rights reserved. Techwatch reserves the rights to all information on this website (texts, images, videos, sounds), unless otherwise stated.
  • Memberships
  • Advertising
  • Videos
  • Contact
  • Search
Privacy settings

Bits&Chips uses technologies such as functional and analytical cookies to improve the user experience of the website. By consenting to the use of these technologies, we may capture (personal) data, unique identifiers, device and browser data, IP addresses, location data and browsing behavior. Want to know more about how we use your data? Please read our privacy statement.

 

Give permission or set your own preferences

Functional Always active
Functional cookies are necessary for the website to function properly. It is therefore not possible to reject or disable them.
Voorkeuren
De technische opslag of toegang is noodzakelijk voor het legitieme doel voorkeuren op te slaan die niet door de abonnee of gebruiker zijn aangevraagd.
Statistics
Analytical cookies are used to store statistical data. This data is stored and analyzed anonymously to map the use of the website. De technische opslag of toegang die uitsluitend wordt gebruikt voor anonieme statistische doeleinden. Zonder dagvaarding, vrijwillige naleving door je Internet Service Provider, of aanvullende gegevens van een derde partij, kan informatie die alleen voor dit doel wordt opgeslagen of opgehaald gewoonlijk niet worden gebruikt om je te identificeren.
Marketing
Technical storage or access is necessary to create user profiles for sending advertising or to track the user on a site or across sites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}